11 American Dog Food Brands You Should Never Feed Your Dog

Have you ever stood in the pet food aisle, staring at dozens of bags and cans, wondering which one is truly safe and healthy for your dog? You’re not alone. With confusing labels, catchy marketing claims, and a multitude of brands, it can feel impossible to know what to trust. The pain point is real: you want the best for your furry friend, but you also don’t want to inadvertently feed them something that could harm them.

In this article I’ll walk you through eleven American dog food brands that have serious red-flags, documented problems, or ingredient/label issues that many experts believe make them less than ideal for your dog’s long-term health. You’ll also learn why these brands are problematic, what to look for in a good dog food, how to read labels, evaluate ingredients, and what alternatives you can consider.

By the time you finish reading, you’ll have a clearer, deeper understanding of which brands to avoid, why you should avoid them, and what to feed instead—so you feel confident making the right decision for your dog’s diet and wellness.

What does it mean to “avoid a dog food brand”?

Defining the concept

When we say there are dog food brands you should never feed your dog, we’re not always suggesting that every single product from the brand is instantly toxic or will cause sickness. Rather, this means:

The brand has recurring concerns (ingredient quality, recalls, misleading marketing).
The brand tends to rely on fillers, low-quality by-products, or questionable sourcing.
The brand may market heavily, but the underlying nutritional value may be weak or inconsistent.
For dogs with sensitivities, allergies, or health issues, a brand’s weak formulation may carry greater risk.
In a perfect world, you want to minimise the gamble—you want your dog’s food to be consistently safe, nutritious, and backed by reliable manufacturing standards.

Why this matters (benefits of avoiding weak brands)

A high-quality, well-formulated dog food supports strong immunity, healthy digestion, coat/skin health, proper energy levels, longevity, and fewer vet visits.
Feeding a dog food with cheap fillers, vague “meat meals”, lots of corn/soy/wheat-by-products or artificial preservatives may undermine health: more allergies, digestive upset, nutrient deficiencies over time. As one article noted: “Poor-quality ingredients in some pet foods can lead to weakened immune systems and chronic diseases.”
When you’re a dog owner (and you are), you want to minimize risk. Nutrition is one of the biggest controllable variables in your dog’s health.
Avoiding brands with documented problems helps you sleep easier—knowing you didn’t pick the bag just because it was cheap or heavily marketed.

Misconceptions & challenges

“Big brand = safe” — Not always. A recognized brand can still use low-quality ingredients or have recalls.
“Price = quality” — There are expensive brands with weak formulations and cheaper brands that are better. You have to look at ingredients, sourcing and transparency.
“My dog is fine on it” — Just because your dog appears to do okay now doesn’t mean the food is providing optimal long-term nutrition or avoiding subtle risks (allergy buildup, organ stress, etc.).
“All foods are pretty much the same” — No. There is wide variation in ingredient quality, digestibility, and formulation. Some brands invest in research, digestibility studies, clear meat-first ingredients; others focus on cost-cutting, filler use, heavy marketing.
“Avoiding a brand means never using any of their products” — In some cases yes, in others you may still feel okay feeding a particular product from that brand. But you must evaluate carefully.

How to evaluate a dog food brand and product

Before diving into the list of brands to avoid, let’s give you the tools to evaluate dog foods yourself—this way you empower yourself (not just rely on lists).

What to look for in a good dog food

Meat (whole meat or named meat meal) listed first: A quality brand should start with something like “chicken”, “beef”, “salmon meal” etc.
Named protein sources: Avoid vague words like “meat by-products” without naming the animal.
Appropriate macronutrient balance: Dogs need a balanced diet of protein, fat, and digestible carbohydrates. Too much filler (corn, wheat, soy) is common in weaker formulas.
Minimal fillers/unnecessary ingredients: Cheap grains, corn gluten meal, wheat middlings, excessive artificial colours/flavours/preservatives are red flags.
Clear formulation for life-stage: Puppies, adults, seniors, large breed, etc.—formulas should specify and meet relevant nutritional guidelines (e.g., by Association of American Feed Control Officials – AAFCO).
Reputable manufacturer with transparency: Manufacturing standards, recall history, ingredient sourcing matter.
Digestibility and health outcomes: If you can find reviews or studies showing dogs thrive on the food (good stools, good coat, good energy), that’s a positive sign.

What to avoid / red-flags when reading ingredient lists

Corn, wheat, soy listed as first or major ingredients: These are cheap fillers and often less digestible for dogs.
Unspecified “meat meal” or “animal by-products” without clarification of source.
Artificial colours/dyes (Yellow #5, Red #40, Blue #2, etc.).
Artificial preservatives like BHA, BHT, propylene glycol used as moistening agents.
High amount of carbohydrate fillers (especially cheap carbs) rather than quality protein/fat sources.
Frequent or major recalls or lawsuits related to the brand. (Not every recall means you must avoid a brand, but it should raise caution.)
Marketing claims that override substance: “Premium”, “gourmet”, “real meat” don’t guarantee quality; always check the label.

When to consider your dog’s specific needs

Allergies / food sensitivities: If your dog has digestive upset, itching, skin problems—ingredient quality and avoidances matter even more.
Life stage / breed size: A formula for a small breed adult is not the same as large breed puppy or senior.
Health conditions: If your dog has heart issues, joint issues, weight problems, the food must support those needs (not introduce additional problems like too much fat, too many carbs, etc.).
Transitioning foods: When you switch foods, do gradually over 7–10 days to avoid digestive upset.

11 American Dog Food Brands to Avoid

Below are eleven brands that show recurring concerns—from weak ingredient profiles to recalls, lawsuits or pattern of filler usage. The objective is to help you understand why many experts recommend avoiding them entirely or with extreme caution. If you currently feed one of them, you might want to reconsider and evaluate alternatives.

1. Alpo

Alpo is a long-established American dog food brand (founded 1936) by Nestlé Purina.
Reasons to avoid:

According to one investigative article, Alpo’s products “containing below-average protein and fat but above-average carbs when compared with other dry dog foods.”
Use of low-quality ingredients such as corn, corn gluten meal, soybean meal, unidentified bone meal and artificial colors.
The brand has been connected with recalls and concerns over quality.

What that means for you:
If your dog eats Alpo regularly, you may be feeding them a higher-carb, lower protein diet, which may not optimally support muscle maintenance, coat health or long-term vitality—especially for active or large breeds.

2. Beneful

Owned by Nestlé Purina, Beneful is well-known and widely marketed.
Reasons to avoid:

Contains cheap grain fillers and unidentified by-products. The “worst brands” list flags corn/soy, animal digest, artificial colours and large number of preservatives.
A class-action lawsuit was filed alleging harmful contents (though the company denied wrongdoing).
Despite marketing as “real meat” and “healthy”, ingredient quality was questioned by independent reviewers.

What that means for you:
Even though Beneful is heavily marketed and accessible, the underlying ingredients may not support the best nutrition. If you value ingredient transparency and optimal nutrition, this may not align with your goals.

3. Cesar

Cesar (often known for small-dog cans) is another popular brand.
Reasons to avoid:

Products contain meat by-products, corn and gluten meals, whole grain corn and artificial colours.
High sodium content reported (especially in canned small-dog lines) and may not meet the ideal high-quality protein standards.

What that means for you:
If you have a small breed, you might be tempted to choose Cesar—but the cost-savings and convenience may mean a trade-off in ingredient quality and long-term nutrition.

4. Gravy Train

Another well-known brand (originally introduced in 1959) now owned by Post Consumer Brands.
Reasons to avoid:

Historic investigation found that out of 15 cans, 60% tested positive for pentobarbital (a euthanasia drug) in some batches.
The food primarily uses by-products from corn, wheat and soybeans, bone meal, artificial colours, etc.
The “gravy” marketing hides the fact that nutritional quality may be weak.

What that means for you:
This brand is problematic from both ingredient-quality and safety perspectives. With the pentobarbital concern, many specialists say it should be avoided altogether.

5. Iams

Iams has been around for decades, but concerns have been raised.
Reasons to avoid:

Contains unidentified meat by-products, corn, brewers yeast and beet pulp (which some link to heart-disease concerns in dogs).
Recalls and quality complaints have emerged in past years.

What that means for you:
Iams may not be the worst dog food out there, but if you are seeking higher-premium, better ingredients, you may find stronger alternatives.

6. Kal Kan

Kal Kan is a legacy brand, but repeatedly flagged in lists of dog food to avoid.
Reasons to avoid:

Uses ground whole corn as first ingredient in some formulas.
Contains cheap fillers, artificial colours, flavours and preservatives.
Some cases of kidney failure were reportedly linked in investigative articles.

What that means for you:
If you’re feeding Kal Kan, you may be feeding a food where nutrient density and quality are compromised in favour of cost savings.

7. Kibbles ’n Bits

Founded in 1981, this brand has a very mixed reputation.
Reasons to avoid:

Independent investigations alleged presence of pentobarbital (euthanasia drug) in dog food from this brand.
Ingredient lists contain corn, soybean meal, wheat, animal digest, artificial colours, corn syrup.
Often described in pets-forums as “junk food” for dogs.

What that means for you:
Many dog-nutrition experts deem this brand one of the weaker ones in terms of ingredient quality, safety transparency and formulation.

8. Ol’ Roy

A house-brand from Walmart, this is positioned as a budget dog food.
Reasons to avoid:

First ingredient in some cases: whole grain corn.
Large amount of corn, wheat, soy, unidentified meat by-products, artificial colour.
Some investigative articles link it with kidney disease and poor nutritional value.

What that means for you:
If cost is the primary driver, Ol’ Roy may make sense, but from a nutritional standpoint you may be getting significantly less value for your dog’s lifelong health.

9. Pedigree

Perhaps one of the most widely-recognized dog food brands in the U.S.
Reasons to avoid:

Frequently listed among brands to “be cautious about” due to high-carb content (corn, wheat), animal by-products, artificial colours.
Recall history: in May 2024 the brand voluntarily recalled 315 bags of Pedigree Adult Complete Nutrition due to possible presence of loose metal pieces.
Recently subject to lawsuit alleging excessively high vitamin D levels in some kibble.

What that means for you:
Even if your dog tolerates it, you might be feeding less-than-ideal nutrition—and your dog may be missing out on better formulation alternatives.

10. Purina Dog Chow (and selected sub-brands)

While Purina has some higher-end lines, many of its mass-market formulas are flagged in summary lists of weak brands.
Reasons to avoid:

Some of its entry-level products contain heavy use of fillers, by-products, corn/soy and artificial colour/preservative-laden formulas.
Because of scale and market saturation, some formulas prioritize cost over premium nutrient sources.
As one review noted, brands you may want to avoid included Purina when reviewing ingredient panels.

What that means for you:
Purina may have some good lines—but if you feed a lower-tier Purina formula, you should examine the label carefully rather than assume brand name equals high quality.

11. Hill’s Science Diet (and similar “premium mass” brands)

Hill’s is marketed as “veterinary” or “science-based” dog food. However, it also appears in some cautionary lists.
Reasons to avoid (or at least be cautious):

Some formulas for “sensitive stomachs” were criticized by vets for containing wheat, maize, rice and oats rather than high-quality digestible proteins.
Ingredient lists can include extensive carbohydrate/starch content, questionable ingredient sourcing, and high cost relative to ingredient quality.
For a brand that charges premium price, you may expect better ingredient transparency.

What that means for you:
Hill’s may have appropriate formulas for certain veterinary-prescribed diets—but if you’re buying a generic adult formula believing you’re getting “top tier” above all others, you should still read the label and consider if there are better alternatives.

Why were these brands chosen?

The selection was based on multiple published lists of “worst dog food brands in America” (see 24/7 Wall St., A-Z Animals, etc.).
Each brand has had documented issues: ingredient quality concerns, recalls, lawsuits, by-product/filler reliance, or safety investigations.
The goal is not to “brand-bash” but to highlight brands where the risk-to-reward ratio may lean too far on the risk side if you care about premium nutrition.
If you currently feed one of these brands, you don’t necessarily have to panic and throw out the bag tomorrow, but you should reevaluate the decision and compare with higher-quality options (more on that later).

Mistakes to avoid when choosing dog food

Assuming “popular” means “good.” Popular brands often rely on marketing; they may command shelf space but not always ingredient excellence.
Only comparing price. A cheaper bag might save you money short-term but cost more in vet visits or reduced quality of life long-term.
Not reading the label. Even within one brand there may be good formulas and weaker ones.
Switching foods too abruptly. Even high-quality foods should be introduced gradually.
Ignoring your dog’s individual needs. A healthy adult dog is different from a puppy, a senior dog, a breed with joint issues or allergies.
Assuming “premium price” means “premium quality.” Some more expensive brands still rely on fillers or by-products; ingredient list matters most.
Overlooking recall history or transparency. Brands that have numerous recalls or lawsuits are riskier—while no brand is entirely immune, frequent issues suggest systemic weaknesses.

Alternatives: What should you feed instead?

If you decide you want to move away from the “brands to avoid”, here are some tips and alternative approaches:

How to pick a better dog food

Look for a named meat (e.g., “chicken meal”, “turkey meal”) as first ingredient.
Avoid or minimise corn-meal, wheat, soybeans listed as first or high ingredients.
Ensure the food is labelled “Complete & Balanced” by AAFCO for the life stage of your dog.
Research the manufacturer’s reputation for transparency, recalls, ingredient sourcing.
Consider consulting your veterinarian especially if your dog has health issues.
Monitor your dog after switching: check stool quality, energy levels, coat condition, any signs of upset.

Some higher-quality approaches

Premium “super-premium” brands (look for reputation, ingredient transparency, high named protein sources).
Grain-free may be appropriate in some contexts (though note the recent caution around certain grain-free diets and heart disease). For example, the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has investigated ties between certain grain-free diets and canine dilated cardiomyopathy. TIME
Specialists or veterinary-grade formulas (if your dog has special needs).
Homemade or raw feeding (only if you’re well-informed, working with a veterinary nutritionist, and comfortable with safe preparation).
Always transition gradually—mix your dog’s old food with the new for 5–10 days, increasing the new while decreasing the old.

Reader-Focused FAQs

Q: If my dog has been eating one of the “avoid” brands and seems healthy, should I panic?
A: Not necessarily. “Seems healthy” is good, but it doesn’t guarantee optimal nutrition. If your dog has no digestive issues, good energy, healthy coat, good vet checks—then you might feel comfortable staying. But the goal here is improvement: if you have the opportunity to upgrade the formulation, it may benefit your dog long-term.
Q: Are all products from these brands bad?
A: No. Some brands may have gone through reformulations or have better lines. But because of the brand’s track record, you should approach their products with more scrutiny: check the particular formula’s ingredient list rather than assuming “brand X is fine”.
Q: What if I can’t afford premium dog food?
A: That’s understandable. In that case: focus on the best formulation you can afford. Prioritise named meat/meal as first ingredient, avoid excessive fillers/artificial colours, choose a brand you trust for transparency. Also, feed correct portion sizes (over-feeding is a big issue).
Q: Should I avoid grain-free dog food because of the FDA heart disease concerns?
A: Not automatically. The FDA’s investigation found links between certain grain-free diets (high in peas/lentils/potatoes) and canine dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). But some grain-free formulas may still be perfectly good—what matters is overall ingredient quality, nutrient profile, and suitability for your dog. If your dog is eating a grain-free diet, it may be wise to consult your vet and ensure it meets all nutritional needs.
Q: How often should I check for recalls or ingredient changes?
A: Regularly. A brand may change its formula or supplier without as obvious a notice. You might set a calendar reminder every few months to check the manufacturer website or recall lists (for example, via dog food advisor services) and re-review your dog’s food label.
Q: If I switch foods, what should I expect?
A: Transition gradually over about a week to 10 days: start with 75% old food and 25% new, then 50/50, then 25/75, then full. Watch for stool consistency, appetite, energy level, coat sheen. If you notice digestive upset or drop in appetite, slow the transition.
Q: Can cheaper dog food ever be fine?
A: Yes—price doesn’t always equate with quality, and budget constraints are real. The point is to look at what you’re getting for the money. A reasonably priced food with a strong ingredient list and reputable manufacturer can be a very good choice. The issue is when cost-cutting results in weak nutrition.
Q: Should I always avoid all “mass-market” brands?
A: Not necessarily. Some mass-market brands do produce solid formulas. But because many of them rely on inexpensive ingredients or large scale manufacturing, they often present higher risk of weaker nutrition or less transparency. So treat them with more scrutiny, not automatic disqualification—but in many cases it may make sense to move “up a level” for your dog’s benefit.

Closing thoughts & next step

Feeding your dog is one of the most fundamental every-day decisions you’ll make as a pet owner. While brand names and packaging may catch your eye, what matters far more is what’s inside—the quality of the ingredients, the formulation, the digestibility, and the long-term impact on your dog’s health.

The eleven brands above are not automatically “poisonous”—but they represent brands where many experts believe you’d be better served choosing something else with fewer compromises. If you’re currently using one of these brands, your next step is simple: pull the bag from your shelf, read the ingredient list, compare it to a higher-quality formula, and decide whether the change would be worth it.

Your dog deserves better nutrition—something that supports vitality, longevity, lean muscle, healthy skin and coat, good digestion, and the energy to enjoy life. Give yourself the confidence that you’re choosing the best possible food for your companion.

Next step for you: Open the bag of your current dog food, look at the first five ingredients. If meat isn’t first, and you see lots of corn/soy/wheat or “animal by-products” unnamed, it may be time to explore alternatives. Pick one new formula from a trusted brand, transition over 7–10 days, monitor your dog’s health, and make that change count.

Your dog will thank you—and you’ll feel much better knowing you’ve made an informed, thoughtful decision.

You may love this one: Top 10 Dog Food Brands to Be Careful With in Australia